Alert Regarding Significant Law Change – the SECURE Act

Gold Leaf Estate Planning, LLC

POSTED ON: January 19, 2020

Alert Regarding Significant Law Change - SECURE Act

What the Secure Act Means for Minnesotans

On December 20, 2019, President Trump signed the Setting Every Community Up for Retirement Enhancement Act (SECURE Act). The SECURE Act, which is effective as of January 1, 2020, is likely the most impactful legislation affecting retirement accounts in decades. The SECURE Act has several positive changes: It increases the required beginning date (RBD) for required minimum distributions (RMDs) from your individual retirement accounts from 70 ½ to 72 years of age, and it eliminates the age restriction for contributions to qualified retirement accounts. However, perhaps the most significant change will affect the beneficiaries of your retirement accounts: The SECURE Act requires most designated beneficiaries to withdraw the entire balance of an inherited retirement account within ten years of the account owner’s death.[1]

The SECURE Act does provide a few exceptions to this new mandatory ten-year withdrawal rule: spouses, beneficiaries who are not more than ten years younger than the account owner, the account owner’s children who have not reached the “age of majority,” disabled individuals, and chronically ill individuals. However, proper analysis of your estate planning goals and planning for your intended beneficiaries’ circumstances are imperative to ensure your goals are accomplished and your beneficiaries are properly planned for.

Under the old law, beneficiaries of inherited retirement accounts could take distributions over their individual life expectancy. Under the SECURE Act, the shorter ten-year time frame for taking distributions will result in the acceleration of income tax due, possibly causing your beneficiaries to be bumped into a higher income tax bracket, thus receiving less of the funds contained in the retirement account than you may have originally anticipated.

Your estate planning goals likely include more than just tax considerations. You might be concerned with protecting a beneficiary’s inheritance from their creditors, future lawsuits, and a divorcing spouse. In order to protect your hard-earned retirement account and the ones you love, it is important to understand the impact of the SECURE Act on your estate planning.

Conduit Trusts and the Secure Act

Your trust likely includes standard “conduit” provisions, and, under the old law, the trustee would only distribute required minimum distributions (RMDs) to the trust beneficiaries, allowing the continued “stretch” based upon their age and life expectancy. A conduit trust protected the account balance, and only RMDs–much smaller amounts–were vulnerable to creditors and divorcing spouses. With the SECURE Act’s passage, a conduit trust structure will now require the trustee to distribute the entire account balance to a beneficiary within ten years of your death.

The significant downside to the SECURE Act, aside from the income tax impact it will have on your beneficiaries, is the impact that it will have on the asset protection for your beneficiaries as it relates to your retirement accounts. Once the retirement account has been liquidated after the 10-year period following your death, the retirement account money will be in the hands of your beneficiary and will not be protected from creditors.

Accumulation Trusts and the Secure Act

For those of you who are more concerned with asset protection, one alternative is to use what is called an “accumulation trust”. This type of trust for your beneficiaries is an alternative trust structure through which the trustee can take any required distributions and continue to hold them in a protected trust for your beneficiaries. Thus, although the retirement account must still be liquidated after ten years, the trust for your children may hold the money for much longer.

A potential downside to an accumulation trust is that if the trustee holds the retirement account distributions rather than distribute them out to the beneficiary, the trust becomes exposed to the “trust tax rates”. This is why, prior to the passage of the SECURE Act, many trusts were drafted as conduit trusts to avoid the tax impact. For 2020, if a trust has taxable income over $12,950, the effective tax rate is 37%. As such, an accumulation trust, if it is not distributing income out to beneficiaries, could result in a significant amount of tax.

Other Considerations for Estate Planning Under the Secure Act

For most Americans, a retirement account is the largest asset they will own when they pass away. If we have not done so already, it may be beneficial to create a trust to handle your retirement accounts. While many accounts offer simple beneficiary designation forms that allow you to name an individual or charity to receive funds when you pass away, this form alone does not take into consideration your estate planning goals and the unique circumstances of your beneficiary. A trust is a great tool to address the mandatory ten-year withdrawal rule under the new Act, providing continued protection of a beneficiary’s inheritance, even though it is over a shortened time period.

Review Intended Beneficiaries

With the changes to the laws surrounding retirement accounts, now is a great time to review and confirm your retirement account information. Whichever estate planning strategy is appropriate for you, it is important that your beneficiary designation is filled out correctly. If your intention is for the retirement account to go into a trust for a beneficiary, the trust must be properly named as the primary beneficiary. If you want the primary beneficiary to be an individual, he or she must be named. Ensure you have listed contingent beneficiaries as well. If you have questions about your beneficiary designations, be sure to contact us.

If you have recently divorced or married, you will need to ensure the appropriate changes are made because at your death, in many cases, the plan administrator will distribute the account funds to the beneficiary listed, regardless of your relationship with the beneficiary or what your ultimate wishes might have been.

Other Strategies for Dealing with the Secure Act

Although this new law may be changing the way we think about retirement accounts, we are here and prepared to help you properly plan for your family and protect your hard-earned retirement accounts. If you are charitably inclined, now may be the perfect time to review your planning and possibly use your retirement account to fulfill these charitable desires through a charitable remainder trust.

If you are concerned about the amount of money available to your beneficiaries and the impact that the accelerated income tax may have on the ultimate amount, we can explore different strategies with your financial and tax advisors to infuse your estate with additional cash upon your death through the use of life insurance.

If you are concerned mostly about the tax impact this will have, a conversation with your financial advisor about converting from a traditional retirement account to a Roth retirement account may be appropriate. With a Roth conversion, you will pay income tax now on the amount converted, but the distributions from that account in the future will not be taxable.

Please feel free to give us a call or send us an e-mail to discuss the impact that the SECURE Act will have on your estate plan.


[1] If a beneficiary is not considered a designated beneficiary, distributions must be taken by the fifth year following the account owner’s death. Common examples of beneficiaries that are not designated beneficiaries are charities and estates. See Treas. Reg. § 1.401(a)(9)-3, Q&A (4)(a)(2) and 1.401(a)(9)-5, Q&A (5)(b).